I’ve seen endless “most scenic thru-hikes” lists pop up every year, and I’m not buying into the hype this time around. Every season brings its own batch of faddish recommendations backed by glossy photos and influencer shout-outs, but where’s the hard evidence that these routes truly live up to the claims?
After decades on the trails, I’ve learned that what’s deemed “scenic” can be highly subjective—and often, overhyped trails end up more crowded and less rewarding than lesser-known alternatives. So here’s the challenge: Which thru-hike routes are you all finding genuinely breathtaking for reasons that go beyond the trendy snapshots? And how do you weigh actual wilderness quality against the social media appeal?
I’m curious if any of you long-time hikers have discovered underrated trails this year that offer honest-to-goodness scenery without the fluff of commercial marketing. Let’s spark a debate that cuts through the glossy veneer—what are your real recommendations, and what about some popular routes just didn’t meet your expectations?