I’ve been using traditional trekking poles for over 20 years, and now all the hype is around these extendable models. Proponents say they’re lighter and more compact, but I’m not convinced they’re as robust as the fixed designs I’m used to. Has anyone really put an extendable pole through its paces on rugged trails? How do they hold up in terms of stability, durability, and overall performance when the skins are off?
I’m particularly concerned about the extendible mechanism—does it lock securely enough to safely support a hiker on uneven terrain over long distances? I’ve read mixed reviews, with some users reporting failure or slippage during critical moments. Are these cases isolated, or is there a fundamental design flaw nobody is addressing in the forums and magazines?
I’m open to updating my gear, but only if there’s clear, field-tested evidence that these new poles aren’t just a gimmick. Would like to hear detailed accounts and comparisons from those who’ve transitioned from fixed to extendable poles.